Belgian Malinois vs. Rottweiler – Which One To Choose?

The Belgian Malinois and the Rottweiler are both strong, intelligent, and highly-protective breeds capable of providing various services to their owners. However, there are some key differences between the two dogs. Both dogs have been used for centuries in military and police work, but they were originally bred for different purposes. These breeds can also have many hours of fun, but their powerful protection in the home and neighborhood make a choice difficult.

While they share many common traits, each brings distinctive qualities. The Belgian Malinois and the Rottweiler have a long history together. Both breeds were originally developed for the military and have spent centuries protecting their owners. They both bring different traits to the table.


AttributesBelgian MalinoisRottweiler
Good For First Time Owners No No
Good Guard Dog Yes Yes
Apartment FriendlyPossible With Enough Exercise Yes
Good Family Dog With Training Yes
Shedding Moderate To High Moderate
Barking And Howling            Moderate To High Low
Height    22-26 inches (56-66 cm)25-27 inches (64-69cm)
Average Life Expectancy  12-14 Years 8-10 Years

Belgian Malinois – Dog Breed Information

The Belgian Malinois is a powerful and intelligent dog with a strong guarding instinct. He is compact, agile, and muscular, with a square and broad skull. The Malinois was originally bred to be gentle with livestock, especially goats and all other creatures that are vulnerable to attack, including humans. The Malinois has a very powerful head which serves him well in his job as a protector, but it can also cause damage to furniture and other objects.


Malinois dogs are typically gray and black, with a tan coat and a black muzzle. The colors of the Malinois’s coat can include white, black, red, brown, and tan. Malinois should have a muscular build with a square and broad skull. The Malinois has a flowing carriage which gives him an overall athletic look.

Males are 24 to 26 inches tall and weigh between 65 to 80 pounds.

A female dog can reach up to 22 inches (56 cm) in height and weigh up to 70 pounds (27 kg).


The Malinois is a courageous breed that is intelligent and alert but can be stubborn and dominant. He is athletic and agile and also has a proper guarding instinct. Malinois are very protective of their families, especially their owners. They are loyal and caring towards their families but can also be very independent and may not be the best guard dog. Malinois are agile, moving their bodies from the fast-moving and more alert hunting dog to the heavy-duty, aggressive combat dog.

The Malinois is an intelligent dog that can learn new tricks quickly and is easily trained. They are also very sensitive dogs that respond well to verbal commands. They do not like being ignored or yelled at and will stop working immediately when they feel ignored. Malinois get along with children but should be supervised near children due to their fast-moving nature. Malinois are very energetic dogs that tend to get bored easily and require mental and physical exercise, especially when young.

Grooming & Care

Malinois are very easy to groom. They have short hair and generally do not require much grooming. Malinois are very clean dogs that can get their fur brushed regularly. If a Malinois has long hair, it is advised to clip it to avoid tangles. The Malinois is also known to shed its hair once or twice per year, and it is advised that owners brush their dog’s coat before they shed their new coat of hair as it is easier for them to maintain the cleanliness of their coat this way.

The Malinois should be bathed at least once a month using cool water and mild shampoo.


Malinois requires a lot of care and training. They are hyperactive dogs that require plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to stay mentally fit. Malinois can be stubborn dogs given the right training methodology, but they can learn quickly if taught properly. Malinois are very intelligent dogs and can be trained easily with proper training methods, but they require a lot of time and patience to learn simple commands.

The Malinois has been known to be a stubborn dog, so it is advised that owners take extra time to train their dogs because it takes all of the dog’s attention to understand the owner’s command while training them.

Rottweiler – Dog Breed Information

They’re fierce, intelligent, and dedicated to working hard and being good friends. The Rottweiler is a huge, muscular dog breed that originated in Germany. The Rottweilers have a muscular look with short fur on their bodies, but they have long hair in the form of a mane. The Rottweiler has a muscular, lean body and a long, stiff tail. A Rottweiler’s head is similar to a mastiff’s but more rounded.

Rottweilers are extremely loyal companions and make good guard dogs and watchdogs for their masters because of their size and temperament.


The Rottweiler has the appearance of a mixed-breed dog. The Rottweiler has the appearance of a mastiff and a bloodhound. The Rottweiler has short fur on their body, but they have long hair running down their backs as a mane. The fully grown male can reach as tall as 69 cm and weigh as much as 130 pounds (60 kilograms). A female’s height reaches 25 inches (64 cm) and 115 pounds (52 kg).

Temperament & Personality

The Rottweiler is a very gentle and loyal breed to own. You must ensure you respect your dog’s emotional needs, especially since they need to be treated with kindness, and children should be homeschooled so as not to startle your pet in any way or for them to become frightened by other dogs. The Rottweiler is a very good guard dog, but its friendly nature makes it a wonderful companion for the family.

Grooming & Care

The Rottweiler needs to keep itself well-groomed. If a Rottweiler looks like it hasn’t been bathed in two weeks, it is best to take them to the vet because its fur can get very dirty and matted. The coat sheds twice a year heavily during those seasons. You need to groom the Rottweiler often because they cannot stand being dirty, and if they feel uncomfortable or sick, they will refuse to go outside or walk themselves.

It can also become stressful because they are uncomfortable, so you need to look after them as much as possible by keeping them clean, well groomed and healthy for them.


It would help if you took your Rottweiler to a dog trainer, which is the best way to train them. They are friendly and trainable dogs and will listen to you well. They don’t mind training, so you have to let them know what you want them to learn by using positive reinforcement. When trained, they’ll be very good at things like ‘sit’ and ‘stay.’ In fact, in some countries, including the UK, where I come from, the Rottweiler is used as a police dog because of its high level of intelligence.

Belgian Malinois vs. Rottweiler – The Differences Explained

The Belgian Malinois is the most common dog. They were originally bred to work alongside canines in the king’s service and remain a vital asset to the Belgian police force today.  The dogs have quite different temperaments and acceptance factors. Regarding conformation and structure, Belgian Malinois and Rottweilers feature great temperament and moderate athletic ability.  Rottweilers are incredibly large and require a lot of room, but their short fur makes them easier to maintain and may be better suited for indoor living.

Malinoises are less demanding than Rottweilers but still need some grooming work. These two breeds are not recommended for inexperienced owners. They’re working breeds that must be exercised daily. Rottweilers and Belgian Malinois are considered active guard dogs and require daily exercise of at least one hour to gain the desired temperament. A Rottweiler behaves better if properly socialized, but children are more friendly and gentle with dogs.

The Belgian Malinois is on the healthier side when it comes to health compared to the Rottweiler from a genetic standpoint. Rottweilers have around three years less longevity compared to other dogs. They’re also a bit more vulnerable to health issues and allergies.


The right owners should consider both of these breeds as excellent choices. Both make great family dogs, but the Mals are better suited for families with children. If you need an agile working dog, the Rottweiler will be your best bet. The Malinois is a more powerful and stable dog but a bit more dependable regarding obedience training. Both are loving and loyal dogs that need to be trained properly. If you’re looking for a working dog, Rottweilers are more suited for the job. I hope you like our article. If you have questions about one of the articles, please comment below.






Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *