Do you have some experience in dogs? Or even better, have you taken a class in Dog Training? If yes, then you have a great foundation to help you.
So let us start with the history of these two breeds. The one common thing is that their history dates back to the Middle Ages and its German roots. Both breeds are very similar in appearance but have a few major differences.
So let us have a look at them in detail.
- 1 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: History & Origin
- 2 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: Their Genetics
- 3 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: Personality
- 4 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Grooming
- 5 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Health Issues
- 6 Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Trainability and the Exercise Needs
- 7 Final words on Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: History & Origin
First lets clear a few points that may confuse you. The Belgian Shepherd is not actually a Belgian though he was originally bred in Belgium as an official military dog. So now we know that the Belgian Malinois is not actually from Belgium and is white in color.
The German Shepherd originates from Germany and therefore has a solid yellowish-tan coat, almost like sheep-skin.
The only difference between the two dogs are that the German Shepherd has double coated ears, clawing ability and a lax attitude to training, hence making them excellent for Police work than Malinois But again these are minor differences.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: Their Genetics
Let’s talk about their genetics. The Malinois is an offspring of the Belgian Sheepdogs, which are originally from Europe. These dogs have been bred up with Mastiffs and Terriers over the past 300 years.
Basically, this breed was created by breeding them with all kinds of dogs, mostly the ones that had a lot of foreign blood in it (already explained above) and often with larger breeds like Great Danes to increase the size of their size and more importantly their muscle strength.
So these dogs are known to have a very high level of intelligence and a very high level of energy. They also possess a highly trainable disposition, allowing them to be easily trained for various purposes like as Military Police Dogs or even for Search & Rescue work or Protection work like in Australia’s Police Force.
The German Shepherd originated from Germany as a local dog breed since 1800s. These dogs were raised mostly for agricultural work, either as shepherd dogs or to protect the farm animals. They were also used for hunting boars and deer.
The German Shepherd has been a very popular dog breed throughout the world, so it is not surprising that other countries wanted to have their own version of this breed.
One of them, the Australian Shepherd, was born in 1936 which brought a bit of changes in these dogs by altering the head shape and adding some new traits like erect ears and shorter hair pasted coat.
Nowadays these two breeds are considered two different breeds but both are actually one German Shepherd with different history and origin. Another notable example is the Newfoundland dog which was originally used by fishermen in Canada’s Newfoundland province back in 1920s to keep watch over their boats at night since they can climb trees well enough.
They have also been used along with other breeds to guard them during rough weather conditions as well as acting as a workmate by pulling sleds when going for a day trip to the mountains.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: Personality
As you can see, the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd have very similar origins and history. But this doesn’t mean the two breeds are of the same temperament and personality.
They have both been bred for different purposes, such as for hunting, guarding (like in Belgium’s police), or working on farms. Because of this, both breeds are very intelligent can be trained easily but this also makes them harder to train by themselves to some extent.
Both dogs have strong protective instincts that don’t allow them to get along well with strangers but some dogs in both breeds are able to be friendly around strangers even if they don’t understand the new environment. On the other hand, the Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd both have a very high level of energy which makes them very active dogs.
So, if you’re looking for an energetic dog breed that can also work alongside you, it’s highly recommended looking into these two breeds, although both of them can be good for families with kids.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Grooming
The two dogs are both short-haired but the German Shepherd has always been used as a farm dog, so it is kept short and it has a protective coat. The Belgian Malinois, on the other hand, was bred to be effective at hunting. So it has longer hair and it also has an outer guard coat which is longer and thicker than the one used by the German Shepherd.
That being said, both breeds have similar grooming needs which are two times a week for brushing with a rubber brush or comb and bathing only when necessary.
Additionally, both breeds need daily teeth brushing because their teeth will eventually rot out if they don’t brush regularly. Moreover, you don’t need to clip your dog’s nails unless he’s using them to scratch a wound.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Health Issues
Both Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd can suffer from some health issues that you should be aware of because they’re both high-energy dogs like their ancestors so they’re prone to dental issues as well as joint issues even if they have been vaccinated regularly against them.
They can also suffer from hip dysplasia, heart problems, seizures and several other ailments that are hard to predict so you need to be careful in selecting a dog of this breed.
Additionally, both dogs are prone to eye problems that can be a serious burden for the owner and they can be fixed with the help of veterinary ophthalmologists or optometrists.
Overall, both Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd are very similar in terms of their health needs and you should check the health history of any dog you plan to purchase as it usually gives a lot of information about its future health needs.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: The Trainability and the Exercise Needs
The Belgian Malinois is a very intelligent dog that can learn commands very quickly due to its sensitivity but it is active most of the time and does not require much exercise.
Remember that if you’re looking for a dog for hunting purposes, training your Belgian Malinois is essential because it will be the one going after the game in nature.
The German Shepherd is more suitable if you’re looking for an energetic breed that requires daily exercise and you’ll be able to train it well as well as providing it with mental stimulation.
It’s very important that you let your dog play with other dogs because a dog is a social animal.
Additionally, both Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd love human contact so they’re not recommended for people who do not have a lot of free time because they need to spend time with their owners and be cared for.
Final words on Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd
They’re both very active and intelligent dogs that are great for people who have a lot of free time. You should choose a Belgian Malinois if you want a dog that will be part of your family or the pack and you need a guard dog because it will protect you from intruders.
On the other hand, if you want an energetic dog that will require a lot of daily exercise, then a German Shepherd is the one for you.
When choosing between them, you should also consider the breeders who are considered some of the best in the world and would be able to guide you on choosing the right dog.
So at last, Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd is one of the most talked-about topics in the world and people are arguing about it all the time.