Belgian Malinois vs. Doberman – Which One To Choose?

Malinois is a Belgian Malinois and Doberman Pinscher Hybrid. They have similar traits, and the main differences between these breeds are their abilities, size, temperament, and appearance. Malinois are known for their intelligence, loyalty, and courageous nature. They are one of the best guard dogs. They can do anything an American police dog would do.

They have a strong protective streak, due to which they’re highly valued as police dogs. If you need a friendly dog with your kids and easygoing at home, then Malinois might fit you best.  On the other hand, Doberman is a hardworking dog of large size with an intimidating appearance and powerful physique.

Doberman is known for his bravery and obedience; he’she’s able to respond to commands in a quick moment as a pro soldier does. Dobermans are great family dogs; they don’tdon’t play too much with children but love to spend time with adults around the house however, if you want to have reliable protection from criminals.

Attributes    Belgian MalinoisDoberman
Good Guard Dog Yes   Yes  
Good Family Dog With Training Yes  
Shedding Moderate To High Low To Moderate
Good For First Time Owners No Yes  
Height 22-26 inches (56-66 cm) 25-28 inches (64-71 cm)
Average Life Expectancy 12-14 Years 10-13 Years
Apartment Friendly  Possible With Enough Exercise Yes  
Barking And Howling       Moderate To High         Moderate

Belgian Malinois – Dog Breed Information

The Malinois is a Belgian military dog breed, and it was developed for tracking terrorists and other enemy soldiers. The Belgian Malinois is a fighting dog; they can be trained to fight with their partners or alone. But it is a good guard dog or security service. This breed has a short coat in various colors, such as black, yellow, brown, and red. They have a head that is large with a flat skull and small ears that are close to their heads.

The eyes are dark and intelligent, as well as the strong jaws of this breed. They have two different types of coats; brindled coats and smooth coats. The brindled coat is usually black all over with white markings.


The Belgian Malinois is a very versatile dog. It can be used as a loyal and intelligent guard dog. It can be used as a home protection service, as police or military work, and of course, as a family dog. Its long legs help it move around easily, but they are also small enough to fit through most doors. It has a large head and chest. The neck is always strong when the head is large; strong jaws are without overgrown teeth. The tail is high and makes a curve but never hangs down to the back of the dog.

Males can reach up to 66 cm in height and weigh up to 80 kg. A mature female can weigh up to 60 pounds (27 kg). Belgians are known for their heavy shedding, two-phase shedding season.

Belgian Malinois Temperament and Character

The Belgian Malinois is a very loving and loyal breed. It is also known to be an intelligent working dog. They have a strong guarding instinct that will alert you of intruders, but it is rarely aggressive. It has a strong sense of obedience and will be the perfect companion for any family. The Belgian Malinois tends to be stubborn, making training sessions more difficult than others, which makes them more difficult to train.

When they are not trained properly, these dogs can develop hostile behaviors because they will hold grudges against you for not paying attention to their training or failing to meet their needs as your canine companion.

Grooming & Care

Belgian Malinois is a very low-maintenance dog. It requires minimal grooming and care. Some owners will bathe their dogs once every few months, while others may only choose to bathe their dogs monthly.


Since they are intelligent, the Belgian Malinois is easy to train. They are known to respond well to positive training methods, but owners cannot teach tricks or commands such as sit, stay, or heel (walking on a leash). If you plan on taking your Belgian Malinois for obedience training classes, ensure you take it as soon as you get it home from the breeder or rescue center. Belgian Malinois learn very fast, so if you wait too long, you will have an unruly dog when you finally start training it.

Doberman – Dog Breed Information

Originating from Germany, the Doberman has been one of the most popular watchdogs for decades. They are good at guarding and alerting the owner to danger. They bark and howl when they sense something is out of the ordinary. They have a strong sense of smell and warn off intruders by barking or growling. Doberman Pinschers, aka Doberman Dogs, are a very sturdy breed known for their strength and intelligence.

They can be protective animals that like to play rough with other dogs and humans. They are stubborn when training, so owners use body language to get them to understand what they want to be done while not taking too much time with this breed type.

Male birds reach up to 27 inches (69cm) and 90 pounds (41kg).

At age 26, a male reaches 77 pounds (35 kg) and has 66 inches (157 cm) of hair.

Grooming & Care

Dobermans usually require minimal grooming requirements since they have short hair, which makes it easy to clean up after them. Owners should brush their dogs once in a while but only minimally since doing so can make your dog less happy and less likely to respect you as its master if you decide that the brushing needs an increase in the frequency of some sort at some point in time down the road after you’ve had your Doberman for awhile longer than a year or two years old.

If you own one with long hair, then brushing it regularly is required every few days or weeks, depending on your preference. When it comes down to choosing between having long hair or short hair, Doberman pinscher puppies alike. I believe there is no wrong choice for the most part. Bathing dogs with short hair, like Dobermans, is also not required.

Still, it is recommended every once in a while for hygienic purposes as well, especially if you decide to get a dog with long hair that you are worried about her having fleas because some breeds of dogs have difficulty getting rid of these little parasites.

For this reason, you’d want your Doberman pincher always to be clean, though i don’tdon’t think taking a bath all the time is good advice for long-haired dogs.

Doberman Temperament

Doberman Pinchers are a breed of dog with a lovely temperament, and it’s not too difficult to see why from their looks. Even though they have such long and powerful canines, Dobermans are still some of the gentlest dogs you could ever come to own. There is no doubt about this; Doberman pinschers have wonderful temperaments and are very easy to deal with for people who have them as pets.


Doberman training is an awesome prospect for the owners of these dogs, and it can be very helpful for those who wish to take care of their pets well. This means raising them well and teaching them how to behave in many ways. As you know, dogs are considered a prideful breed, and they tend to be stubborn when training them.

Thus it becomes necessary for you as the owner to always supervise your dog’sdog’s actions closely, listen carefully when it comes to what he or she is saying, and also make sure that you don’tdon’t use harsh manner of words while dealing with him or her.

Belgian Malinois vs. Doberman – The Differences

The two breeds are visually and structurally distinct. However, when we compare their temperament and behavior, some things make them distinct in other areas.The first difference is their temper: Dobermans are much calmer, while Belgian Malinois are much more reactive and excitable. If you have a bit of patience and discipline, you can get good results with them, which will be an advantage for you.

They also differ regarding their obedience level: the Belgian Malinois is quite obedient, but they are not very responsive to commands, while Dobermans are much more responsive, so it will not be a difficult task for you to train them. Another big difference is their size and weight: Dobermans are bigger and heavier than the Belgian Malinois but longer. In antlers, Dobermans are similar to the Malinois, while in bone, they are a bit bigger.

Having a thick undercoat and longer fur makes them more suitable for outdoor activities no matter the season. They can even join your family for a day on the slopes.The Doberman is better for novice owners, while the Malinois usually requires some prior experience with dogs.

Both breeds need a fair amount of exercise given their small size and do not require a lot of space for running around. This is what made them so popular in the military: they were used as sentry dogs due to their high level of intelligence. Despite their powerful appearance, their movements are very agile and fast.

If you live in an apartment or a small house with little outdoor space or have a limited budget for dog’sdog’s spending expenses, these dogs will be your best choice. They have few health problems compared to other big breeds and do not require an extremely large living area!


If you want to find the best dog breed, it is always a good idea to do a little study and research the various breeds. This is especially true if you live in a city and do not have much space or money for your dog. The more you know about the Dog Breed Standards, the better your choice will be. When you decide on a breed, you will also find out how much it costs to own, feed, and take care of different breeds.

Of course, all dogs require certain amounts of care and money, so it all depends on how much you can spend. However, it is good to know that there are still many free dog breeds. I hope you like my article. Suppose this was helpful to you, please like, and comment. Please let me know in the comment box if you have any questions about dog breeds. Thanks for reading, and have a nice day.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *